Mere Orthodoxy

has been moved to new address

http://www.mereorthodoxy.com

Sorry for inconvenience...

Mere-Orthodoxy: 04/01/2005 - 05/01/2005

Saturday, April 30, 2005

Help, I've been Memed

My brother has passed on to me the oh-so-infamous Farenheit 451 meme. You can read all about its history at Jim's site. You are stuck inside Fahrenheit 451. What book would you be? As my brother points out, it's rather a strange question at first glance. I'll not repeat his explanation (since you should have already read his post). Though I'm tempted to choose The Everlasting Man (just because walking around being called "The Everlasting Man" would be kind of fun), I am impelled to choose Chesterton's other masterpiece Orthodoxy, the book that revealed the overwhelmingly beautiful truths of Christianity. Have you ever had a crush on a fictional character? Not that I can remember, though Beatrice in Dante's Paradisio almost did it for me, I think. I can't tell if it was her or the poetry. I think the poetry. What was the last book you bought? You'd think from the above titles it would be something as snobbish as Milton or as esoteric as Eliot. You would think. You'd be wrong. It was How I Trade Options, by Jon Najarian. What are you currently reading? For my Academy classes, I am reading LOTR. I'm currently half way through (at the beginning of book four). It needs no explanation, but I will say I have been particularly struck by Tolkien's use of Providence to move his plot and the forces of good along. For my business interests, I'm digesting Najarian's book (above). Options seem to be a good investing vehicle for people with little capital and low risk thresholds like me. For my marriage prep, I'm reading through Passionate Marriage. I highly recommend it, though I'm only 3 chapters in. Of course, this week is also Plato week for me, if that counts. I'll be spending long hours ruminating on love, rhetoric, and relationships with Dr. Al Geier and Plato's Phaedrus. What five books would you take to a deserted island? I'll take "book" to mean either "bound pages" or "an intentionally unified work" (as in the last choice). That said, I'd take my UBS 4th edition, and for the others I'd (begrudgingly!) limit myself to Plato's complete works (the height of Greek thought), Dante' Divine Comedy (the height of Medieval thought), my Riverside Shakespeare (the height of Renaissance thought), and Barth's Church Dogmatics (the height of Modern thought) . Whom are you going to pass this book meme to and why? Jonathan, though my hunch is he'll spurn it. Update: Reverse psychology works. Jonathan took my challenge, broken link and all, and proved himself sufficiently more nerdy than me.

Tuesday, April 26, 2005

Egalitarian Histories and the Claims of Scripture

The next couple days I'm going to revist a couple recent posts where people have left insightful comments that I would like to fully respond to. I'm going to begin with this post regarding PZ Meyer's post about giving "proper reverence" to everyone who has gone before us, rather than singling a certain tribal people (Jewish) out for special honor. Meyer's post was a smash hit, as the comments indicate. It was featured in Carnival of the Vanities and made it to the new Smarter-than-I carnival (a creation of my brother) by "popular demand." Kevin Keith, who I am guessing is from leanleft, made the following quite lengthy and helpful comment. I would encourage you to read the whole thing and then peruse my comments at the bottom. You didn't understand the post. [Myers] first evokes the immense temporal history of "human" or hominid species - extending back over 1 million years for Homo spp. and at least 4 million or more years for Australopithecus spp.. He then notes that the Bible, whatever else it might be, is essentially a record of the current Homo species over the most recent span of about 2,000 years (some quibbled with his dates, arguing it covers historical events as long as 3 or 4,000 years ago, but his basic point remains). Thus, the Bible - whatever it has to tell us and whatever it records - accumulates (some of) the human experiences and wisdom of only 1/75th to 1/50th of our species's history, 1/500th or so of our immediate ancestors' history, and 1/2,000th to 1/1,000th of what might reasonably be called "human" history. And, he notes, it is a profound and moving document - but one limited to only a tiny fraction of all that may have been known or seen in our history. His observation is that if we are to hold the experiences - and what was learned from them - of people who lived 2,000 years ago in reverence, as he believes we should do, then it is almost heartbreakingly sad to note that the equally fraught, equally noble experiences of their ancestors, and those ancestors' ancestors, and so on all the way back have been lost without any but the slightest record or remembrance. The experiences, hopes, fears, and beliefs of those earlier humans are as awesome and as worthy as those of humans in the time of King David, or today - and it would take thousands of Bibles to tell even the bare outlines of their stories, yet we have not a page or a line from them. The Bible - a record of the most ambitious and inspirational aspects of human history - covers only a hair's-breadth of the span of the full story of human experience and belief. Pre-H. sapiens species had social rituals, including formal burials with flowers and artifacts, that speak of deeply-felt emotions and conceivably of religious beliefs, as well as of organized social structures. Their stories are part of our story, and they must be fascinating, but they are lost. The stories we do have of "early" humans are actually quite recent in terms of the whole span of human history, and given how moving those stories are, what is lost to us must be of incalculable value. This leads to two conclusions: (1) we should recognize our history and beliefs - including the Bible - not as unique or as some sort of culmination of an historical trend, but as a continuation of a long history whose prior inhabitants had their own stories, beliefs, triumps, tragedies, and hopes - equally valuable and equally inspirational as compared to ours; and (2) we should avoid over-exalting the Bible as the last word on anything, when in fact it is just the most recent word, dwarfed by the 98.67% to 99.95% of human history that it doesn't mention. This is hardly a radical observation - it is simply the importation into social history of the obvious and well-known facts of biological history (i.e., that we are merely a continuation of a long evolutionary line, and not yet a very long-lived branch of that line as well). The import of this observation is to encourage us to remember and feel for the (almost always overlooked) truly human experiences and imaginings of our pre-historical and immediate evolutionary forebears, and to remember as well to keep our understanding of the Bible and its significance within its very limited historical context. Your remark that "it's ALSO the revelation of God of the Universe who happens to be nothing less than the source and center of all meaning" is irrelevant. Human history is (at the outside) over 4 million years long; the Bible covers a period of a couple of thousand years that ended almost 2,000 years ago. Even if there is a god who created this world and dictated the Bible (a god who, bizarrely, seemed to need to crib much of it from the Epic of Gilgamesh, and then set his followers to take a vote on which of its many versions was supposedly the one actually dictated), the fact can't be changed that most of what has happened in the world isn't part of the Bible, and virtually all of human history was lived before the Bible was composed. Those humans' history and experiences are as valuable as ours; their joys and sorrows were surely as inspirational as ours, their events and doings surely as inspirational, their beliefs and aspirations surely as heartfelt. The Bible records none of it - which is to say that the Bible is not the pinnacle of human wisdom but merely the surviving fragment of a vast store of wisdom and experience that was (likely) never written down. And so we should value it for what it is, but not more than that, and take up the burden of trying to discern what else there is that might be known for ourselves. To believe the Bible is the first and last word on everything is to deny the obvious fact that there were hundreds of thousands, and indeed millions, of years of experience with, no doubt, every topic mentioned in the Bible that came before the first Bible story was conceived. The Bible thus can't be the first, nor likely the last, word on anything. And so we honor it as a partial record of a tiny fraction of a noble history, but no more than that because it cannot, in actual fact, be and is not anything more than that - even if (some, a, the) god did dictate it. Somehow that god forgot to dictate the other 1,999 volumes, leaving us on our own to discover what else we might have - and may someday - know besides.

I appreciate Kevin's tone and his engagement with us here at Mere-O. We're always looking to welcome new readers.

I appreciate his attempt to help me understand the post, though I did have a good understanding of it when I wrote my original post. What I didn't understand was why people were so impressed with it. I think I do now.

Myers' post and Keith's recapitulation rest on an egalitarian view of human history, a position that suggests all time-slices of history are created equal. They provide no grounds for this position, though they do assert it repeatedly and vigorously. They are particularly intent on defending the time-slice of "pre-history," or the human experiences had before the time of the Bible that are (quite frankly) unknown to us. Claims about this "pre-historical" period are obviously tendentious and speculative.

However, it is interesting that they claim these unknown histories are "just as valuable as our own." Let me grant this for a moment--what makes history valuable at all? My own philosophy is that history is valuable because it gives a sense of self-identity--it informs my perception of my self and my place in the cosmos.

Yet this account of history destroys any egalitarian notion of history. Certain time-slices of the cosmos have obviously been radically more influential on our self-understanding and sense of identity as human persons (which most philosophical naturalists are bent on unmaking) than others. I take it that the events of Scripture (even limited to ad.0-33) have shaped human identity immeasurably. The whole concept of a person, after all, began as category of Christian theology. There was no sense of auto-biography before Augustine began working out the Trinity, because there was no such thing as the self. What Myers and Keith call "pre-history" had no such effect on our human identity, at least not in any way that we might recognize. Why are we being asked to put on an equal plane experiences that we have no record of and that seem fundamentally the same as our own?

I'll be more to the point. Keith writes, This leads to two conclusions: (1) we should recognize our history and beliefs - including the Bible - not as unique or as some sort of culmination of an historical trend, but as a continuation of a long history whose prior inhabitants had their own stories, beliefs, triumps, tragedies, and hopes - equally valuable and equally inspirational as compared to ours; and (2) we should avoid over-exalting the Bible as the last word on anything, when in fact it is just the most recent word, dwarfed by the 98.67% to 99.95% of human history that it doesn't mention.

Keith presumes that there is something intrinsic about more data or more experience that contributes to wisdom. I'm at a loss as to even understand how that might be. I am curious to know what he means by "wisdom," since I have doubts that it is the sort of "wisdom" that Plato, Aristotle, or Aquinas might have appealed to.

Furthermore, Keith misunderstands the approach to Scripture that I and most other Christians have. The question is not one of time, but one of truth. Keith (and Myers) are so caught up in a garden-variety chronological snobbery--whereas chronological snobbery for Lewis meant veneration of things new, for Keith and Myers it means veneration of time above truth. Fundamentally, if Scripture is as it claims to be (namely, the historical record of the revelation of the God of the Universe), the length of the time-slice that it happens in seems utterly irrelevant. We as Christians (or as natural philosophers) are not interested in the first word, nor the last word--only the true word. Scripture claims to be the revelation of God to man--if true, then it is The Word and demands reverence and obedience. It does not merit this by virtue of anything other than it's veracity. If it is true, then it is more valuable than any other history, for it claims to inform where Man comes from, who Man is, where He is going, and most importantly, who the Lord and Maker of the Universe is--Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Invitations Hat Tip

Creative guru Allison Howell, who is also a good friend, has recently started an invitation business. I was going to lavish praise on her, but then I realized that I'm not able to really capture how highly I think of her and her work, which you really must see. She is flat out good at what she does and also very reasonably priced. I am a huge fan of small businesses and I really hope Allison's succeeds. If you know of anyone approaching their wedding or in need of invitations for any other reason, send them to her.

Sunday, April 24, 2005

King for a Day

Mark at Pseudo-Polymath is dreaming about what he would do if he were king. His first item of business? Education. An excerpt: However beyond that (with one exception below) the only thing We would require of our primary education system is that it teaches its students how to be good students, i.e., how to learn well. In order to learn well a student needs four "canonical" education skills: Memorization, Reasoning, Dilligence and Perseverance. If your students remember what you say, connect the dots, are careful, and work hard they will excel. If they improve at those things, no matter what they are learning now to practice those skills, when they arrive at their place of secondary education if they are not prepared a the particular class, they will be a quick study in catching up. There is an exception to my granting a complete freedom of curriculum. The one exception is drawn from history. The Ancient Greeks all read Homer, in Greek no less :). An educated Englishman of the 15th-17th century all were read Euclid, the Bible, and a number of other common texts. A common "canon" of texts given to our students to give them a shared set of national symbols to facilitate communications would be a really good thing. I think it would be wonderful if we could come up with 3-8 texts we all have studied carefully and learned well. However, I don't have any good suggestions for what those texts should be. Deciding that small number of texts which should all be engaging as well as deep enough to provide material for life's lessons should be an amusing and lively discussion. Now, Mere-O is largely in favor of serious education reforms. Our preferred type of learning is what might be called the classical educational model. Rather than narrowing the canon to 3-8 texts to give students a "shared set of national symbols," we would advocate a much larger number of texts designed to give the student an understanding of "western thought."*** Progress is only progress if you don't repeat someone who has gone before. Furthermore, we would be suspicious of a "complete freedom of curriculum." It seems to presume that all books or ideas are equally important, which I find indefensible. Furthermore, Olson neglected perhaps the most important aspect of any education: Truth. Olson wants to develop "skills" in students, but it's not clear what those skills are beneficial for other than the discovery or acknowledgment of true statements about the world. "Skills" such as thinking, memorization, etc. are not ends-in-themselves, but only means to-an-end, an end which needs no justification. After all, what exactly are you "learning" if you aren't coming to understand true statements about the world? Incidentally, some of our readers might notice that the above complaint could also be applied to Sayer's essay Lost Tools of Learning. They would be correct. I am looking forward to hearing about more reforms from Mark. It's a great series! ***The astute reader will point out that what we call "western thought" may have had serious influences from the "east." This is quite likely true. However, it seems plausible to label "western" those books which shaped "western culture," even if they are influenced by the east.

Matt's Media-Life Update

Thanks to Grace Hill Media, I've recently become more "in tune" with what's happening in Hollywood. I am really starting to enjoy thinking about media and the possibilities of communicating messages to broad audiences. With this topic in mind, I attended Biola's Media Conference today. Among the highlights:

  • I don't know if it will be a very good docu-drama, but hearing Steve Borden (a.k.a. Sting) talk was awesome. Borden was funny, genuine, and downright honest about his life during and after his career as a pro-wrestler. Hearing his stories was a lot of fun!
  • I got to see clips from The Visitation, a new movie that Ralph Winter is working on. The Visitation is adapted from Frank Peretti's book of the same name. It will be interesting to see if Winter is able to turn a profit on it at all. He has much better prospects with the Fantastic Four, which I also saw the preview to. It looked to me like a run-of-the-mill comic book flick, but then again, I'm no expert.
  • Perhaps most exciting was a never-before seen preview of Narnia: The Lion, Witch and the Wardrobe. They had finished it (or mostly finished, at least) last night at 6:00, just in time to show it at the conference. For those worried about the movie's fidelity to the books, they pointed out that Douglas Gresham, who is Lewis's son and proprietor of his estate, is a co-producer on the movie. The movie looks really, really, good. It was fun to get a sneak peak at it.

It was a great day--I met some fantastic people and made some great connections. My only disappointment was that I didn't get to meet the fantastic people from Grace Hill. I'm sure they had a representative there, but I didn't run into him.

Saturday, April 23, 2005

"What the bleep do we know?"

If you haven't heard of this cinematic sleeper hit, it's about time you did. It's a hybrid documentary/narrative intended to undermine the dusty, stale certainty in which many people spend their bored and boring lives and restore them with the fresh, uncertain vibrancy available only to those with the guts to stomach it. A daring combination of science, spirituality, and philosophy, with interviews with top physicists and killer cgi special effects, the film succeeds in being informative and experiential. Check out the trailer for a taste. The film has been recently released on DVD.

Wednesday, April 20, 2005

We May Have been Wrong

Recently, Mere-O featured a story in the Independent about previously unknown Greek texts being deciphered. It turns out the story may not be a story at all. From Hannibal at arstechnica: So as of right now, the rest of the papyrological community is waiting to hear Dirk Obbink at Oxford either back up for disavow the claims made in the article. At the very best, the Independent's reporters are covering some kind of new imaging breakthrough in an extremely hyperbolic fashion. And at the worst, they're trying to make a major story out of 20-year-old news. Hannibal (ostensibly) is "currently taking a papyrology seminar at University of Chicago with the head of the SBL papyrology group and...working on texts from Oxyrhynchus." Two retractions in as much as a week. Ouch! (ht: a good friend who really needs to be blogging)

66th Christian Carnival Up

And yet it is Mere-Orthodoxy's first. Mark Olson at Pseudo-Polymath is hosting the 66th Christian Carnival. For those not "in the know," Carnivals arrange blog-posts thematically. Olson has arranged his liturgically. This post was our first entry. For those newcomers, we always welcome comments.

Tuesday, April 19, 2005

Fun Reading on the New Pope

First, read Andrew Sullivan's responses to the announcement of the new pope, here and here and here. Then read Bainbridge's response here. He politely says what everyone is thinking. Then check out Dr. Reynolds riff on Sullivan's second post here. The money quote: Sullivan: His theology is indeed distinguished, if somewhat esoteric and at times a little odd. Reynolds: Any bets on how many Ratzinger books Sullivan has actually read? I'm going to aim high and guess two. Perhaps RomanCatholicBlog says it best: Then again, how else would Sullivan react? Short of Benedict XVI had come out on the balcony and declared, "Everything I said before about homosexuality? Fuggedaboutit! Gays can get married!", nothing would have made Sullivan happy. To quote The Blogger, "Heh."

Short-Term Missions and the Priorities of the Evangelical Church

I was perusing Jeremy Pierce's site and I saw the plug for the latest Christian Carnival. I've not yet entered any of my posts in the Christian Carnival, but as churches around the country are warming up the vans and buses and opening up the wallets to send out short-term mission teams, I thought I would issue my complaint against short-term missions to the broader Christian blogosphere. That's right--I have a complaint about short-term missions. In the interest of full disclosure, I have never been on a short-term missions trip. I have never been on a long term missions trip. I am sure that after going on one my views will change radically. Until then, though, I'll keep my arguments. My major argument is simply that the overwhelming emphasis on short-term missions drains the church of resources that would be better spent elsewhere, particularly (and here comes my bias) in the education of the parishoners and the students that are being sent. This year I have been approached by several students with "support letters" for their trips to China, Brazil, and other foreign lands. However, I have yet to be approached by a student with a "support letter" for their college tuition. For some reason, we are expected to support a student spending two weeks in the middle of Papua New Guinea and leave the student who wants to attend Biola--a very expensive venture, mind you!--to the willing arms of the banks and lenders. Students must forge their own way to Christian colleges (or secular colleges, for that matter!). Why? Fundamentally, the emphasis on short-term missions (which may not, in themselves, be bad, though I have my doubts!) neglects the proper care and feeding of the Church at home. Ultimately, it rests on whether a University education (and a specifically Christian University education) is more fruitful than a two-week missions trip to Zimbabwe. For some reason, two-weeks in Mexico building houses doesn't seem nearly as formative as 4 years in a Christian environment learning Christian truths from Christian professors. If I am investing in the Kingdom and if the goal is long term results, my money is going to go to the college, 10 times out of 10. Just to be clear, the argument is not against missions per se, but against a misplaced priority. Short term missions (I'm sure) are changing lives and communities around the world, but does indoor plumbing for another tribe in Latin America really justify ignoring the continuing education of the Church? Why should my students have to sink themselves financially just to get a Christian education? The argument may become more severe if the Federal and State governments ever limit use of Federal funding to wholly secular and state institutions (which, I think is possible). California has proposed reducing their substantial Cal-grant program, which would make it significantly more difficult for students to attend private universities. The problem is further compounded for those of our high-schoolers who wish to enter full-time ministry as a profession after they are trained (yes, any vocation is a ministry, but we sure pay Bible translators a whole lot less than bankers!). The catch-22 is that most pastors end up being paid very little relative to the amount of debt they have to accrue so they can become a pastor. By over-emphasizing short-term missions, evangelical churches (and I think they are primarily guilty of this!) are cutting off their heads to save their hearts and hands--but that's a fairly boring critique by now, isn't it? Something really should be done. We all know by now that evangelicals need to value the life of the mind (see Mark Knoll, JP Moreland, et. al.) but it seems time to put our money where our mouth is. The above complaint is just the kind my brother likes: intuitive, lacking empirical evidence or hard research, and controversial. I have developed it after watching church after church unreflectively endorse short term missions and pour millions of dollars in to sending teams all around the world. My finger may be way off the pulse of the evangelical world, but I doubt it. Update: Removed the blurb about the missions focus. I guess I'm a week late (and still several million short for my cause!).

Monday, April 18, 2005

The Sort of Thing Mere-O Goes Nuts Over

From the Independent:

Now, in a breakthrough described as the classical equivalent of finding the holy grail, Oxford University scientists have employed infra-red technology to open up the hoard, known as the Oxyrhynchus Papyri, and with it the prospect that hundreds of lost Greek comedies, tragedies and epic poems will soon be revealed.

In the past four days alone, Oxford's classicists have used it to make a series of astonishing discoveries, including writing by Sophocles, Euripides, Hesiod and other literary giants of the ancient world, lost for millennia. They even believe they are likely to find lost Christian gospels, the originals of which were written around the time of the earliest books of the New Testament.

The original papyrus documents, discovered in an ancient rubbish dump in central Egypt, are often meaningless to the naked eye - decayed, worm-eaten and blackened by the passage of time. But scientists using the new photographic technique, developed from satellite imaging, are bringing the original writing back into view. Academics have hailed it as a development which could lead to a 20 per cent increase in the number of great Greek and Roman works in existence. Some are even predicting a "second Renaissance".

Christopher Pelling, Regius Professor of Greek at the University of Oxford, described the new works as "central texts which scholars have been speculating about for centuries".

(HT: Decorabilia)

Saturday, April 16, 2005

Mind and Media Review: Seeds of Deception

This is the first official review of the (Lord willing!) many I will be doing for Mind and Media. Some books, no matter how badly written, still merit a reading on other grounds. Georgiana Preskar's Seeds of Deception, which is self-published through AuthorHouse, is one of these. Contra the laudatory comments about her book she (understandbly) puts on her website, Preskar's writing style is downright bad. Preskar includes a small taste of the kind of writing to come on the back of her book: "The journey of one woman, asking why, discovers mind control of our American youth." It reads like some of the sentences from my high school students at the beginning of the year. The bad writing style isn't just limited to grammar. Preskar attempts to frame her findings within her process of discovering them. Rather than gaining a deep compassion or understanding of Preskar's experiences, I found myself laughing out loud at the awkward self-awareness of her comments: "I turned off the computer. My body was not mine. I felt numb. Anita Brayant where are you? (sic) I thank you for your courage" (100). At times, Preskar's book sounds more like a rally than an investigative work: "Make sure sex Ed values are like your family values. Get out of thought revolution and in touch, once again, with traditional values. Parents need to be in control, no the schools. Parents need to check whether classes teach that life begins at contraception and not birth" (89). The lack of clarity that this almost-english teacher despises transfers over to her argument. What is Preskar's point? Preskar's general thesis (I think) is that the educational program Seeking Educational Equity and Diversity is secretly subverting traditional morality and society and replacing them with "global sovereignty, moral relativism, unisex, abortion, assisted suicide, redistribution of wealth, humanist religion, homosexuality, and court decisions and laws that meet the situational needs of the person or persons at the moment" (from the website). Preskar can't restrain herself to simply addressing SEED and it's effects--rather, she manages to take on many of the issues in the above list as well as some that aren't (such as "White Privilege"). She even has sections dedicated to outlining the occultic influences on Hitler as well as the association of the Third Reich with the homosexual cause. Presumably she is attempting to argue against both homosexuality and paganism by association with the Third Reich, as well as point out the similarities between the culture that bred Naziism and our own. However, much of Preskar's "research" rests on rather dubious sources such as The Pink Swastika." However, if Preskar is right about SEED, then she is right to be concerned. From the SEED website above comes excerpts from this article by Emily Style, on of the co-directors for SEED: For me, the beauty of the classroom gathering lies in its possibilities for seeing new varieties of Beauty. This multiplicity, in turn, enables both students and teachers to be engaged in conversation about an evolving definition of the beautiful. Such dialogue requires the practice of both/and thinking as participants acknowledge the varied experiences of reality which frame individual human perspective. Now, the common sense of needing to provide both windows and mirrors in the curriculum may seem unnecessary to emphasize, and yet recent scholarship on women and men of color attests abundantly to the copious blind spots of the traditional curriculum. White males find, in the house of curriculum, many mirrors to look in, and few windows which frame others' lives. Women and men of color, on the other hand, find almost no mirrors of themselves in the house of curriculum; for them it is often all windows. White males are thereby encouraged to be solipsistic, and the rest of us to feel uncertain that we truly exist. In Western education, the gendered perspective of the white male has presented itself as "universal" for so long that the limitations of this curriculum are often still invisible. The proponents of SEED just happen to be behind everything I think is destroying America. If this is what SEED promulgates, then Preskar and I agree. I'll be more charitable to Preskar: drawing off the "scholarship" (see here and here and here) of Dean Gotcher, Preskar identifies Hegelian influences in SEED's pedagogy. From the language of the website, this actually seems a tenable claim to make. Judging from the context, "dialectic" doesn't mean a discussion directed toward finding a normative truth, but a discussion aimed at discovering other people's "personal truths" and learning to accept them as equally valuable. As a philosophy of education, I think this straight from the pit of hell (to join Preskar in her over-the-top language!). That being said, Preskar's argument (if there actually is one!) suffers from her tenuous claims and odd associations. For instance, she argues that the prevelence of circles in the classroom comes from pagan beliefs that time is circular, not linear (page 45). "Schoools increasingly are using the circle, and in Elk Grove it is reported that high school teachers are using it regularly in certain classes. The students report to parents they do not like it." Additionally, rejects any sort of discussion classes, claiming that it is a tool for brainwashing (the facilitator leads the class to the 'evolving higher truth'). She even manages to reject critical thinking, spurning the California Civic Book for it's purpose statement: "The primary purpose of this textbook is not to fill your head with a lot of facts about American history and government. Knowledge of facts is important but only in so far as it deepens your understanding of the American constitutional system and its development." Never mind that I come from an evangelical Christian institution where we sit in circles, have discussions, and attempt to think critically about the world, while still affirming absolutes. Preskar routinely demonstrates an inability think critically or carefully about the associations she draws, as in the above examples. She even accuses Rick Warren and his seeker-sensitive methodology as being a part of this pernicisous movement. The problem with Preskar's work is that fundamentally, when discussing allegedly secretive institutions, the arguments rest heavily upon personal anecdotes. It becomes a matter of whether we trust the authors giving the anecdotes, and Preskar destroyed this reader's trust that she is actually making true claims about SEED and it's method. One of Preskar's like-minded compatriots confirms her claims (in much more clear, systematic fashion!) here, but the problem of trust remains the same. The method of inquiry doesn't lead to highly persuasive arguments--Preskar and her ilk seem to operate in a closed circle of accusations that are impossible to argue with and rest on testimony. Fundamentally, there is no arguing with a position like this. Proofs or arguments that contradict hers are proofs or arguments that I've been brainwashed. This type of water-tight position isn't an indicator of truth, though if Chesterton is right, it may be an indicator of madness (something I am NOT accusing Preskar or her associates of). Regardless, her project of raising awareness would be more successful in certain non-extremist corners (like mine) if she tempered her over-the-top alarmist language with more rigorous argumentation and careful expression. I began the review by Saying Preskar's book is worth reading, if only once, and I still stand by that, though I will admit that it is a borderline case. Much of Preskar's research comes from other sources, and while reading it I often wanted to inquire for myself from the original sources. However, Preskar's book is a litany of interesting theories, many of which I had never come in contact before. For that reason, I would Seeds of Deception, but with the caution that it may be laborious to the critical reader.

I was Wrong

I am very happy to issue my first major retraction on this blog. I feel that somehow I have crossed the threshold as a blogger--I speculated about a turn of events and was laughably wrong! After posting about Grace Hill's alleged rejection of smaller bloggers, I received an email from a Grace Hill representative asking me to call them. During a very pleasant exchange with a delightful young lady, I discovered that they HAD been emailing me the last month, but I was not receiving them. Biola has put in place a new filter for their email server and my suspicion is that it blocked the emails. Little did I know they still were open to our services. I've said it before on this blog: Grace Hill is a fantastic company. With little or no reason to care about a small-ish blog like this, one of their staff members took time to address the concerns I had raised. I'm sure it's difficult to measure how successful particular marketing strategies are, but for Grace Hill's sake, I hope the blogging scheme takes off and gets a lot more people in to their movies. I know the two movies I've seen with them (In Good Company and Constantine) I've highly recommended in any conversation about movies I've had. They're taking care of me and I will continue to do my part to take care of them!

Thursday, April 14, 2005

The painful sting of rejection...

I thought we had a good thing going with Grace Hill Media. Turns out they have (quite understandably!) moved on to more populated waters. I found this post by Josh Claybourn at blogs4god.com (excerpts):

In the mail today I received the pilot episode of NBC's six-hour series "Revelations" which is set to premier Wednesday, April 13 (9-10pm ET) on NBC. Public relations firm Grace Hill Media has distributed the pilot to select Christian bloggers in an effort to tap into the power of the blogosphere.

--

Christians often complain about a lack of representation in mainstream media, but they often fail to admit that modern Christian shows often lack quality screenplays, acting, and production. Such is not the case with "Revelations." which offers a refreshingly well-made series putting Christianity in a positive light. It's truly a production that both Christians and secularists will enjoy.

It's obviously two days old, and I came across it by chance. Surprisingly, I didn't see it on ITA, Claybourn's main blog. I haven't heard anything from GraceHill for a while, which is slightly disappointing. The inevitable is happening--grass-roots blogging campaigns are being replaced by a hierarchized system of 'culture reviewers.' Marketers have to place their product before the most sets of eyes possible, which means it will be increasingly difficult for smaller blogs (such as this one) to take advantage of some of the opportunities blogging has opened up. The more links a blog gets, the better chance it has of getting cool stuff for free.

"To him who has......."

Tuesday, April 12, 2005

Eh?

Will someone tell me what's so great about this post by PZ Myers? If you read the comments, people rave about it, but frankly, it just doesn't seem to be very insightful. Snippets: I am not a religious person by any means (that is a bit of an understatement), but I can feel something of the same reverence for the Bible that I do for a piece of bone. It's a record, spotty and incomplete and flawed, of human lives, that leaves out far more than it includes. It's not as pretty as a bone, but then it is representative of some of the ugliness of human history, as well as of some of the poetry. I can appreciate it as a slice of a few thousand years of the events and beliefs of one fairly influential tribe of people. There are a lot of lives and time, mostly unmentioned, bound up in that book. And:

And, you know, there are people now who claim that one book is sufficient, that it is complete, that it is enough to explain who we are and where we came from.

Strangely enough, these are the same people who claim to be "spiritual". To me, though, they are the ahistorical, unthinking ones who fail to offer the proper reverence due those who have gone before.

Never mind that those silly people think it's ALSO the revelation of God of the Universe who happens to be nothing less than the source and center of all meaning. Never mind that. Silly "spiritual" people. (ht: Decorabilia).

Wholly Unsatisfied

I am discontent with my last post. The last time I sustained a thesis like this was my discussion of Popper. I'm afraid I'm getting rusty...

Scientism and the Death of Wisdom

Many thanks to Joe Carter at Evangelical Outpost for hosting the symposium. Ethics in our ostensibly pluralistic society have become increasingly dominated by a single voice: science. In the 2004 debate over Proposition 71, the California initiative to fund stem-cell research, proponents of the bill played two cards: sympathy and science. TV ads consisted primarily of testimony from individuals suffering from multiple sclerosis, Parkinsons, etc. as well as leading scientists and doctors. The summary arguments in the ballots pitted "non-profit disease organizations, Nobel Prize scientists, doctors, and nurses" versus "women's groups, leading doctors, and medical ethicists." If nothing else, proponents of the bill portrayed their case effectively. Appeal to people's sense of sympathy and show the priests in their garments (doctors and scientists in their lab coats) passionately imploring people to fund medical/scientific research. Not surprisingly, the Proposition passed easily. Standing in direct opposition to this science-dominated policy-making or decision-making is the Judeo-Christian ethical tradition. It is a misnomer, though, to simply call it Judeo-Christian, since the historical Christian tradition has synthesized the teachings of Jesus with those of (primarily!) Plato and Aristotle. Furthermore, the ever-relevant C.S. Lewis argues that the tradition includes cultures and thinkers around the world and throughout history who teach what he calls the Tao, which others have called the "natural law." Contemporary expressions of the natural law tradition argue that there are basic human goods that, given the structure of human nature, are ends to be sought for themselves and not for the sake of anything else. Finnis identifies such things as life, health, knowledge, play, etc. as such goods. These basic rights are not in themselves action guiding, but are principles that moral reasoning depends upon. Indeed, they are not even directives like the 'golden rule,' but stand behind the 'golden rule.' In Aristotle's expression, they are the "First principles of practical reason," and upon them the whole chain of moral reasoning hangs. As Lewis states, "If nothing is assumed, nothing can be proved." Though these goods are not in themselves action guiding, they are the intrinsic ends upon which decisions are made. It is the task for the moral reasoner to determine when and how these prinicples apply to specific moral situations. However, it is the existence of these first principles that a scientific methodolgy eschews. If they exist, they cannot be known because they are not empirically demonstrable. "Human life is a good" is not a claim subject to the domain of science. If our access to the structure of reality is limited to science, then all other claims become, at best, subjective statements that have no bearing on the way things are. In a recent interview, John Gearhart stated: When does 'life' begin I would contend is not a question that biology can answer. Rather, it deals with philosophy or theology. The egg and sperm are alive. Each of us must decide what we mean by 'life.' If there are no first principles of practical reason, no intrinsic ends, then moral reasoning evaporates into the ability to defend claims empirically. Moral dilemmas, which ought to be used as heuristic devices for the budding moral reasoner, are reduced to a single authority (science) and constitute a rejection of moral reasoning--if moral norms do not exist, then nothing can be proved. What this means is a widespread rejection of the virtue of wisdom, the ability to distinguish between competing goods and to make a reasonable and defensible decision. By undercutting the foundation of moral reasoning, scientism creates a people dependant upon the authority of the class of men "in the know," who become the priests and prophets of our day.

Thursday, April 07, 2005

Intellectual vision makes for excellent production.

In an ongoing effort to be radically experimental, the following post is a philosophical dialogue I have written regarding the usefulness of "seeing" what you are going to make before you make it. Please let me know how you like it, if you dislike it or don't quite get it... and also if you have anything to add to the discussion of the two characters, as their subject interests me. And now, with no further ado, untitled dialogue #1. Dramatis Personae: a college student named Nat Tabris and a friend. "Intellectual vision makes for excellent production. What do you mean by this, Nat? That "vision", not the vision of the eyes, but of the mind, is a pre-requisite for creating something and creating it well. That seeing a thing, or perhaps the image of a thing, in "your mind's eye," as it will exist in the medium, is a pre-requisite for any and all good art. Or rather, it is a pre-requisite for any art of any kind (in the general sense, e.g. "artifice")... In other words, how good your pre-art mental map is determines how good the thing will be. I see. That's what I think, but don’t let me get off easily. Let's examine it. How shall we examine it? By answering this question: Is there any contradictory thesis that makes this a bit challenging, and thereby interesting, to maintain? Divine inspiration is another source of excellent production. Yes, but does inspiration come in any other form than intellectual vision? Let's see, in the case of Dante, it does not. The inspiration is a form of intellection. Who else? Chaucer, Plato, Wordsworth, Whitman... Eliot. Take Chaucer. He produced an excellent book, right? Did he "see" this excellent book, before producing it? I do not know enough about Chaucer. I think that's the thesis, right? Yeah, but I do not know much about these others... Perhaps one of our other friends could help us. I definitely think Plato would affirm that inspiration from God is a kind of intellection. Even without examining these artists, I see one exception to this. Which is? Improv. What do you mean? Jazz improvisation artists begin, not with the final goal in mind, but, with a prescience of the parts of the final goal, and they let a spontaneous, spur of the moment assembly take place. Are we missing anything major in this inquiry? Who has thought about this the best, and to whom can I look for initial starting thoughts? Is now the best time to decide that, my friend? No, we were in the middle of a thought. So I'll come back to that question at the end of this train. OK. So, you were saying that improvisation is an exception to your own thesis. Fancy how you contradict yourself! How then we explain improv, of the jazz sort, the rhetorical sort, the humorous sort? It seems to be an employment of methods, already known, to create an arrangement that is new. This "new arrangement" is unforeseen? Yes. But it is possible that it be good? Yes… and often is. Does this disprove your thesis, then? Yes, unless I qualify. Which I'm sure you will. Yes, I will. You can tell me after if I seem to be weaseling out of the argument. I will qualify in the following way: If the parts are foreseen, and if a vague idea of the skeleton upon which these parts will be hung, is foreseen, then some idea, or "vision," of the final product is in fact foreseeable. Let me put it this way: if you know the compononents you will be building with, it is sure what kinds of products will not be produced. By choosing your tools (the parts, or means) and the form (the skeleton, or frame) of the final product, you exclude certain final products, and in that way choose the final product. I agree, and do not think that is weasely. We've reached a sort of an end to that part of the argument, would you like to ask your first question? Yes. It was: are we missing anything major in this inquiry? Who has thought about this the best, and to whom can we look for initial starting thoughts? Well, I'm sure Plato had something to say about creation, and about imaging things. The Timaeus, for instance, has the maker looking at a model, some eidos, by which he creates the world. OK. The thesis is, "intellectual vision makes for excellent production." This seems true, as far is it goes. David Allen affirms as much in Getting Things Done. He says "imagine yourself beyond the completion date." "Imagine success. What did that look like?" Here he is leading his fans to build a vision of what they want, that they might attain it. With that said, however, we have much to research to see what other, more capable men, have thought about the same subject. Until then, let us conclude, tentatively, that you cannot create well without first seeing the whole, or at least the parts. It is concluded, for now."

Tuesday, April 05, 2005

Hart on the Soul

Eastern Orthodox theologian David Hart on the Christian view of the soul: This is not to deny that, for Christian tradition, the soul transcends and survives the earthly life of the body. It is only to say that the soul, rather than being a kind of "guest" within the self, is instead the underlying mystery of a life in its fullness. In it the multiplicity of experience is knit into a single continuous and developing identity. It encompasses all the dimensions of human existence: animal functions and abstract intellect, sensation and reason, emotion and reflection, flesh and spirit, natural aptitude and supernatural longing. As such, it grants us an openness to the world of which no other creature is capable, allowing us to take in reality through feeling and thought, recognition and surprise, will and desire, memory and anticipation, imagination and curiosity, delight and sorrow, invention and art. Read the whole thing (ht Wittingshire).

Monday, April 04, 2005

Papal Roundups

William Rice at Dawn's Early Light has a round-up on what just about everyone is saying about the Pope. There's good reading in them there posts....

ID the Future

There's a new blog for all the ID junkies in the world (I am not one of these!). It's got a slightly qualified list of contributors, too. Check out IDtheFuture.com for a blog that has as it's list of contributors Jay Richards, Jonathan Wells, William Dembski, and Michael Behe, and Jonathan Witt of wittingshire.blogspot.com (a hat tip to him for this one!), where you're just as likely to come across a piece of poetry as you are a post on ID (Witt has a literature Ph.D.). Now if only they would open it for comments....

Evangelical Outpost Symposium

Joe Carter at the Evangelical Outpost has announced the topic for his second symposium. This one has (good!) prizes. For this quarter, I’ve decided to broaden the topic around the theme of Judeo-Christian morality in an ethically pluralistic society. Entries can explore the history of the concept, the applications toward public policy, the best means of arguing for it in the public square, or anything else that you choose. This could be a good incentive for Mere-O to have an "in-house" symposium on this very topic. Put your thoughts together, post them, try to win Carter's prizes. Too bad there are no bonus prizes if we sweep........

Sunday, April 03, 2005

Smarter than I

Brother Jim over at Decorabilia has created a new carnival that he is calling "Smarter than I." (Shouldn't that be "Smarter than me? I thought the first person personal pronoun "I" became "me" when the object of the verb. But Jim, after all, is the English teacher of the group. Well written, thought out pieces that the submitter did not write are what the carnival will feature. My first entry? This post from Brother Jim: We already have enough carnivals where bloggers trumpet their own work. Let's share the love. I propose a new carnival titled "smarter than I," in recognition of those who are too humble, too busy, or too shy to submit their tidbits of genius. Guidelines: Submissions must not be your own. Sorry. That's what other carnivals are for. Choose the best post you've read in the past week or two, perhaps with a brief (1-2 sentence) description or shout-out. There are no other criteria--just good writing, wherever you can find it. Submissions must include the post's title along with a working link, and may include a one- or two-sentence summary. I reserve the right to edit for grammar, spelling, and clarity. If I can't accept your link, I'll be sure to let you know exactly why. Send your entries to smarterthanI at hotmail dot com by 3 pm PST, Monday, April 4. Pass the word along, too, if you get the hankerin'. Update: Unless I'm petitioned for an extension, I hope to have the Carnival up by Tuesday. Thanks to Mark Olson of Pseudo-Polymath for sending in the first entry. Keep 'em comin'... Update Update: Thanks to all the bloggers who've linked to this so far (including those I've missed), and for all those who've sent in their suggestions. So far, most of the entries are from lesser-known blogs, which is exactly what I'd hoped. smarterthanI at hotmail dot com... Okay, so it is the guidelines for the carnival, but it's very well written, and frankly, the idea of having this sort of carnival is flat-out brilliant. I wish we at Mere-O had thought of it. In fact, I'm officially announcing that I'm giving up GodBlogCon (.com!!!!) to think of new unique carnivals to increase Mere-O's traffic.

Saturday, April 02, 2005

Pax Christi.

The AP just reported that the Vatican has released an email announcing the death of Pope John Paul II. The whole world will morun this day the passing of a defender of life, goodness, and peace. From the 1662 Book of Common Prayer, ALMIGHTY God, with whom do live the spirits of them that depart hence in the Lord, and with whom the souls of the faithful, after they are delivered from the burden of the flesh, are in joy and felicity: We give thee hearty thanks, for that it hath pleased thee to deliver our brother out of the miseries of this sinful world; beseeching thee, that it may please thee, of thy gracious goodness, shortly to accomplish the number of thine elect, and to hasten thy kingdom; that we, with all those that are departed in the true faith of thy holy Name, may have our perfect consummation and bliss, both in body and soul, in thy eternal and everlasting glory; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen. Peace of the Lord be always with Pope John Paul II and with us all.

Friday, April 01, 2005

Think twice...

before you decide to take on a developer. Here's an interesting journal of someone who did just that. It's 115 "acts" long, but it's very entertaining, even for someone who doesn't understand the legal jargon. You can go to the website under dispute here. Incidentally, a hat tip to lawreligionculturereview. Radcliffe is a good writer and very well educated. I would recommend his series on the Angels dispute with the city of Anaheim, a dispute for which he has front row seats.